The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution states, “…nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.” This clause of the Fifth Amendment is known as the takings clause. It empowers the government to take private property for public use. Maybe you know someone who had a few feet taken from their front lawn to widen a road or build a sidewalk. The Fifth Amendment also requires that when governments exercise their right of eminent domain that “just compensation” is given to the owners of the property. It allows governments to take private property for “public use” as long as just compensation is paid.
So the natural outcome is that we are all left deciding and defining what is “private property,” what is “public use” and what is “just compensation.”
Well a few years ago there was a big eminent domain case out of Connecticut, Kelo v. New London, 545 U.S. 469 (2005). The long and short of it, the way I understand it, is that Big Pharma Giant Pfizer wanted to build a plant in New London. The city established a private corporation to oversee development in the area. The problem was that a bunch of people still owned homes and lived in the area. The question became whether government can while exercising its power of eminent domain take private property from some people (the homeowners) and give it to other private parties (the New London Redevelopment Corp. that was representing private interests). The big question became what was public use and whether generalized promises of future jobs and future tax revenues could qualify as “public use.” The Court has slowly allowed “public use” to be redefined as public purpose. If the effervescent promise of future tax revenues qualifies as a great enough benefit, just about any government taking of private property can somehow be rationalized as public purpose.
Or as Justice Thomas wrote in his dissent, “Once one permits takings for public purposes in addition to public uses, no coherent principle limits what could constitute a valid public use…” Why not take any house or business if some developer or business is able to somehow show that by razing the existing home/business and replacing it with a new business that government may get sometime down the road the possibility of additional taxes?
I would ask, where is the public use? How is the public able to use the plant that Pfizer wanted to build? We can’t so there is no public use to my non-black robed eyes. The public has no beneficial interest in a privately owned plant. To me it appeared that this was a land grab by government to further the interests of private industry.
Do you think that private entities offering the possibility of future jobs and taxes is enough of a public use to justify government taking private property? I don’t.
The City of New London won and the homeowners lost their homes. End of story? Not quite.
The case was decided in 2005 so what happened to all of the new jobs, new development and new taxes. I want to know.
As Jeff Benedict wrote in the Hartford Courant,
A few weeks ago I visited the neighborhood, ground zero in the famous battle between the city and homeowners. Here’s what I saw: a sea of brown dirt littered with old rusty nails, broken bricks and slivers of glass — the only signs that people once lived there. Every home has vanished. Nothing has been built in their place. The neighborhood is a ghost town, a scarlet letter on the city’s forehead.
No new tax revenues have come. No new jobs have come. No new “public use” has come.
And in another follow-up story, AP writer Katie Nelson notes, “But what of the promised building boom that was supposed to bring up to 3,169 jobs and $1.2 million a year in tax revenues?” There are no new jobs. There are no new taxes. There is no public use. They took the land, kicked the people out of their homes and gave nothing back. Government is controlled by monied vested interests.
Like I always say, if it can happen to them, it can happen to you. On notice is on guard.
GET OUTSIDE EVERYDAY!! ©
So I thought to myself that these scrapings would be great tinder for a firesteel. I didn’t get a fire going, but I guess the point is to always be aware and on the look out for what you may be able to use.
Now that summer is winding down I hope to get back a bit more to blogging.